A fabricated quote is a statement attributed to someone who never said it, or altered from what they actually said. It is a serious breach of both journalism ethics and public relations ethics, since it deceives audiences and can be legally and reputationally damaging for everyone involved. This is general information, not legal advice.
Journalism's ethical codes treat fabrication as one of the clearest violations possible. The Society of Professional Journalists' code instructs journalists to never deliberately distort facts or context, including visual information, and separately to never plagiarize, always attributing work correctly. A quote presented as someone's exact words, when it is not, breaks that standard regardless of whether the underlying fact it supports happens to be true.
The same standard applies on the public relations side of a quote's life. Any organization drafting a quote for a spokesperson or executive must get their explicit approval of the exact wording before it is attributed to them; putting words in someone's mouth without that approval is a fabrication even if a communications team, not a reporter, wrote it. Ethical codes for the profession, such as the PRSA Code of Ethics, require honesty and accuracy in advancing the interests of those represented.
The consequences extend beyond a single release. A fabricated or altered quote that becomes public can permanently damage the credibility of the spokesperson, the communications team and the organization, and it can affect how skeptically journalists treat that source's material in the future.
How to avoid this: 1) Never attribute words to a person without their explicit review and approval of the exact text. 2) If drafting a quote on someone's behalf, mark it clearly as a draft until approved. 3) Keep a record of approval for anything attributed to a named individual. 4) If a quote must be trimmed for space, get re-approval of the trimmed version rather than assuming the meaning is unchanged. 5) If an error is discovered after publication, correct it promptly and transparently.
QUESTIONS
What counts as a fabricated quote?
Any statement attributed to a person that they did not actually say or explicitly approve in that exact wording. This includes quotes invented from nothing and quotes that alter someone's real words in a way they have not agreed to.
Is it acceptable to draft a quote for an executive to approve?
Yes, this is common practice, but the draft only becomes a legitimate quote once the named person has reviewed and approved the exact wording. Publishing it before that approval is a fabrication.
What do ethics codes say about distorting quotes?
Journalism's SPJ Code of Ethics instructs journalists to never deliberately distort facts or context. Public relations codes such as PRSA's similarly require honesty and accuracy, which rules out altering a person's actual statement without their agreement.
What should we do if we discover a quote was fabricated or altered incorrectly?
Correct it promptly and transparently, following your correction policy, and inform the person it was attributed to. This is general guidance, not legal advice, and a lawyer should be consulted if legal exposure is a concern.
SOURCES
Last reviewed